Beware of Pharisees: Let Truth and Mercy Shape the Same Heart
Let Jesus' warning examine your own heart first. Receive the whole truth with humility, and let mercy shape how you teach and treat people.
#328 — Beware of Pharisees
Jun 24, 2024
Play the original Excel Still More episode here without leaving the article.
Begin with your own heart
It's easy to hear Jesus rebuke the Pharisees and think of somebody else. We can become very confident about another person's religious pride while leaving our own untouched. Before using the warning as a label, let it ask something of you. The accusation may even make us feel perceptive while leaving our own conduct untouched. Yet a warning about religious pride loses its purpose if our first use of it is to place ourselves above another person.
Begin with your own conduct, then consider the influence you have with people close to you. Do your words help them understand Jesus, or make it harder to hear him? That question deserves more than a quick defense of your intentions. Before asking whether someone else is an obstacle to faith, ask whether your own speech, assumptions, and habits help people understand Jesus. A Christian can revere Scripture and still need correction in the way it is handled. The aim is neither to weaken conviction nor to win a dispute about who is legalistic. It is to obey Christ with a heart shaped by the truth and mercy He teaches.
Let righteousness reach within
In Matthew 5:20, Jesus says our righteousness must exceed that of the scribes and Pharisees. The teaching that follows reaches into the heart, where resentment and desire can live quietly behind conduct that looks correct to everyone watching. Anger and contempt matter alongside murder; lust matters alongside adultery; truthfulness must govern more than the wording of an oath. Jesus brings the inner life into the discussion without making outward obedience unimportant.
A person can avoid the visible offense and still feed the attitude that leads toward it. Ask what you're allowing to grow when no outward action has yet exposed it. The Lord wants more than a respectable appearance hiding a heart we refuse to examine. We should ask whether resentment, deception, or selfishness has been allowed to live behind apparently proper conduct. Christ's instruction reaches both the heart and the act. An inward claim of love doesn't excuse disobedience, and an outward record of correctness doesn't excuse malice.
Read with mercy and care
In Matthew 12:1–8, the disciples pick grain on the Sabbath and face an accusation. Jesus answers from Scripture, rather than agreeing that a confident religious charge must be right. We need that same willingness to examine the charge before repeating it. He also recalls the prophetic instruction that God desires mercy rather than sacrifice and says the disciples are guiltless. The issue isn't that compassion gives everyone permission to suspend God's commands whenever obedience feels inconvenient.
The accusers needed to understand God's instruction and recognize Christ's authority. Mercy wasn't an exception that made disobedience harmless; it belonged in their understanding of what God wanted. A careless accusation can wound someone while making its speaker feel unusually faithful. When considering another person's conduct, don't rush from unfamiliarity to condemnation. Examine the relevant passage, the facts, and the circumstances. A quick accusation can be especially damaging when it is delivered confidently and later proves mistaken. Taking time to understand is part of taking God's word seriously.
Keep customs beneath God's word
Matthew 15:1–9 shows how tradition can become a way around a clear duty. The dispute begins with ceremonial handwashing, but Jesus brings attention to neglect of parents disguised by religious language. A familiar arrangement still needs to answer to God's command. The claimed dedication of resources to God did not make neglect of a clear responsibility righteous. A practice described in religious language could still contradict God's instruction.
A custom can help without becoming a command. A schedule or teaching method may serve us well for years, then need adjusting when circumstances change. Explain why you use it without making everyone else's faithfulness depend on keeping it exactly as you do. The question is what authority we assign to it and whether it obstructs a duty God has established. Explain the difference between a command and a practical judgment. If a custom can't be changed without someone being accused of abandoning the faith, its biblical basis deserves careful examination. Scripture must govern the custom rather than be made to defend it after the conclusion has already been fixed.
Choose truth over reputation
In Matthew 21:23–27, the chief priests and elders question Jesus' authority. When he asks about John's baptism, their discussion turns toward the consequences of each answer. They consider what would protect their standing instead of simply answering what they believe is true. The text concerns these leaders in this encounter; we shouldn't transfer every accusation indiscriminately to every Pharisee or every person who asks a difficult question.
We face that temptation when a passage threatens a position we've defended. It can become easier to explain away the evidence than admit that our earlier answer needed correction. But protecting a reputation is a poor reason to resist something God's word makes clear. A passage becomes threatening because admitting its force would require explaining a previous mistake. Honest study asks what is true before asking what will protect our standing. If a conclusion needs correction, humility should make that possible. Refusing to learn may preserve an appearance of consistency while keeping us from the Lord whose authority we say we honor.
Receive the whole instruction
Matthew 23:23 names justice, mercy, and faithfulness as weightier matters the leaders had neglected. Jesus also says they shouldn't have left the other duties undone. We need to hear both parts before using the passage to excuse whichever responsibility we find inconvenient. That qualification is essential. The lesson isn't that attention to a particular command proves legalism or that general kindness makes the details of obedience unnecessary.
Selected acts of correctness don't make neglect elsewhere harmless. We may be precise about a public question and careless about the way we speak at home. Ask whether the duty you discuss most eagerly is helping you avoid one you find harder to practice. Someone may insist on honesty in a public argument while concealing facts that would weaken their case. Faithfulness needs the whole instruction of Christ. Ask whether your favorite area of correctness has become a refuge from another duty you find less comfortable. Justice, mercy, and faithful allegiance should shape the way particular commands are carried out.
Serve without the display
Matthew 23:1–12 exposes teaching that doesn't agree with conduct and a desire to be recognized. Later, Jesus compares impressive appearances hiding corruption with whitewashed tombs. These are serious warnings for the person eager to appear faithful while protecting a different private life. These warnings don't authorize us to claim knowledge of every person's hidden motive. They do call us to examine motives we have reason to recognize in ourselves.
How do you respond when nobody notices the help you give? What happens when someone corrects you? Those ordinary moments may reveal a motive worth bringing before the Lord. Let your examination lead to something concrete rather than another judgment about other people. A quiet act of service or a needed apology can give honesty a practical beginning. Neither earns salvation; each can show a willingness to obey rather than protect an image.
Help people come toward Christ
In Matthew 16:5–12, Jesus identifies the dangerous leaven as teaching. Matthew 23:13 shows the harm religious leaders can do by obstructing people from entering the kingdom. Our influence needs to help people hear and follow the Lord, rather than keep them dependent on us. Teaching therefore needs more than confidence and influence. It needs fidelity to God and genuine concern for the people who hear.
Choose an area where your response could become more faithful. Listen before assigning a motive, or take time to show the passage behind a conclusion. When you've made a mistake, acknowledge it plainly. That honesty can make the truth easier for someone else to trust. Keep both the gospel's gracious invitation and its call to obedient faith before the listener. Christ doesn't ask us to choose between truth and mercy. He calls us to let His truth create the kind of people whose mercy, integrity, and faithful conduct help others recognize and follow Him. If you are discussing the lesson with others, keep the language personal enough to invite examination rather than create a list of suspected offenders. Ask what each of you can do more faithfully. Shared humility can make a difficult warning useful without turning the conversation into another exercise in religious superiority.
Take the idea with you.
- 01Where am I protecting my reputation instead of receiving correction?
- 02Does my handling of Scripture help people hear Christ with truth and mercy?
Prefer listening?
The original episode player is available near the top of this article, so you can listen without leaving the page.
