All articles
Relationships•7 min read

Forgiveness Is Complicated: Finding Mercy in Difficult Situations

We all know we should forgive. But what happens when both people are wrong, you cannot name the sin, you disagree about Scripture, or the other person will not repent? Let's think through what love asks of us.

By Kris EmersonOctober 26, 2026#450 — Forgiveness is Complicated - How to Find Mercy in Challenging Situations
Listen while you read

#450 — Forgiveness is Complicated - How to Find Mercy in Challenging Situations

Oct 26, 2026

Play the original Excel Still More episode here without leaving the article.

What to remember
Before you focus on what someone else did, ask God to help you see your own heart clearly.
Being hurt does not always mean someone sinned against you. Be careful about the difference.
You can love someone, pray for them, and refuse revenge without pretending that trust has been restored.

Forgiveness is easy to talk about when we are not the ones who have been hurt. We know the verses. We know what Jesus taught. We believe in mercy. But then something happens in our own family, our marriage, or our church family, and suddenly it is not so simple.

What if both people did something wrong? What if someone hurt your feelings, but you cannot really say they sinned? What if you both believe you are standing for Scripture? And what if someone clearly did wrong but refuses to admit it? Those are real situations, and they deserve more than a quick answer.

Here is where I want us to begin: before we ask what the other person needs to do, let's think about what we ask God to do for us.

Think about how you want God to forgive you

When you go to God for forgiveness, what are you hoping for? You want Him to listen. You want mercy. You want Him to help you change. You want to know that one failure does not have to define the rest of your life. And sometimes you need Him to show you a sin you have not even recognized yet.

First John 1:7–9 reminds us to walk in the light and confess our sins. Hebrews 4:14–16 reminds us that we have a High Priest who understands our weaknesses and invites us to come for mercy and grace. What a blessing that is! God does not pretend our sins are harmless. He loves us enough to forgive us and help us become better.

Now think about the people who have hurt you. Could we offer them some of the patience, honesty, and hope that we want God to show us? That does not mean ignoring sin. It means wanting something better for the person, not just wanting to make them pay.

1. What if both people are wrong?

Have you ever been in an argument where you knew the other person was wrong, but deep down you also knew you did not handle things well? Maybe they started it. Maybe their part was much worse. But you still said something you should not have said.

Here is a question worth asking: Can I own my part without first demanding that you own yours? If I was responsible for ten percent of the problem, I need to take responsibility for that ten percent. I do not have to pretend the other ninety percent was mine.

Instead of saying, 'I'm sorry, but you made me angry,' what if I simply said, 'I should not have spoken that way. I was wrong. Will you forgive me?' Ephesians 4:31–32 calls us to put away bitterness and be kind and tenderhearted. Someone has to be willing to go first. Why couldn't that someone be me?

2. What if my feelings are hurt, but I cannot name a sin?

This one is important. Just because someone hurt my feelings does not necessarily mean they sinned against me. Maybe they made a decision I did not like. Maybe I felt overlooked. Maybe we simply expected different things.

That hurt may be real, and a conversation may help. But before I tell someone they need to repent, I ought to be able to explain what they actually did wrong. Otherwise, I may be asking them to apologize for not doing what I wanted.

What if we approached that conversation with a little humility? 'I may be looking at this the wrong way, but I have been struggling with what happened. Can we talk about it?' That opens a door instead of starting a fight. Romans 12:18 says to live peaceably with others as far as it depends on us. Sometimes that means letting go of an expectation instead of holding on to an offense.

3. What if we disagree about what Scripture teaches?

This can be especially hard among Christians because truth matters so much to us. And it should! We cannot just say that every answer is right. But even when I am convinced I am right, I still have to ask whether I am acting like Jesus.

James 1:19–20 tells us to be quick to hear and slow to speak and anger. Second Timothy 2:24–25 tells us to be patient and gentle when correcting others. So I can stand for what I believe Scripture teaches without becoming harsh, proud, or impossible to talk to.

Try praying this before a difficult conversation: 'Father, if I am missing something, please help me see it. If I understand this correctly, help me explain it with love.' We may not agree by the end of the conversation. But we can both leave knowing we were treated with respect.

4. What if the other person refuses to repent?

Now we come to perhaps the hardest situation. Someone has clearly done wrong, but they will not acknowledge it. What do you do when the apology never comes?

Jesus connects rebuke, repentance, and forgiveness in Luke 17:3–4. We should not act as though a broken relationship has been repaired when someone is still defending the wrong. Trust may take time to rebuild, and sometimes there need to be real consequences.

But notice what Jesus also tells us to do. Love your enemies. Pray for those who mistreat you (Luke 6:27–28). Do not repay evil for evil (Romans 12:17–21). In other words, someone else's refusal to do right does not give me permission to do wrong.

I can pray for that person. I can want them to repent. I can refuse to gossip, retaliate, or become bitter. And when necessary, I can also set boundaries to protect myself or others. Loving someone does not mean giving them another opportunity to cause harm. We can keep our hearts open to repentance without pretending that trust has already returned.

What kind of heart do I want to have?

Think about Jesus on the cross. While people were doing terrible things to Him, He prayed, 'Father, forgive them' (Luke 23:34). He did not call their actions good. He showed us a heart that wanted mercy even in the middle of suffering.

That is the heart I want. I will not always know exactly what to say or how to resolve a difficult relationship. I cannot make someone else repent. I cannot force someone to understand me. But I can ask God to help me be honest, humble, and ready to do good.

Forgiveness really can be complicated. But our next step does not have to be. Look at your own heart. Tell the truth. Own what is yours. Pray for the other person. Seek peace where you can, and use wisdom where you must. Above all, remember how much mercy you have received from Jesus—and let that mercy change the way you treat people.

Think about it

Take the idea with you.

  1. 01Is there a conflict where I need to take responsibility for my own words or actions before focusing on someone else's?
  2. 02Am I holding someone guilty because they sinned, or because they disappointed me?
  3. 03How can I show genuine love to someone while still being wise about trust and boundaries?
From Excel Still More

Prefer listening?

The original episode player is available near the top of this article, so you can listen without leaving the page.

Don’t stop here

Choose your next step.

Search the whole library for what is on your mind, open today’s Bible reading, or move into a New Testament chapter study.